Michael, before the Tots
Shame so complete that the onlookers must look away.
Names an embarrassment so total that the witnesses suffer it more than the person enduring it. The audience covers its eyes, leaves the room, or finds sudden business in the kitchen.
Scholars note that many speakers of the language report being unable to witness the original event at all, and know it only by reputation. The phrase is therefore often said with the eyes closed.
In use
Guest: The best man's toast was twenty minutes about the bride's ex.
Guest: I went to stand by the coat check. Michael, before the Tots.
Etymology
From the account of the schoolchildren to whom Michael, years before, had promised to pay for college. When they had grown and were ready to collect, they held a celebration in his honor, and he stood before them to explain that he would not be paying.
Source
Season 6, Episode 12 — Scott's Tots.