Michael, at the Dundies
An honor nobody asked for, bestowed with total sincerity.
Names a ceremony that its organizer loves and its honorees endure. Awards are given with genuine affection and received with genuine dread.
The phrase is used of office parties, family reunions and most end-of-year celebrations.
In use
Employee: The CEO is giving everyone personalized superlatives at the holiday party.
Employee: Michael, at the Dundies. I'm getting 'Most Likely to Leave Early.'
Etymology
From the accounts of the Dundies, the yearly awards Michael gave his people at a chain restaurant, with trophies he named and presented himself to honorees who had not asked for them.
Source
Season 2, Episode 1 — The Dundies.