Dwight, Sprinkles in the freezer

A mercy indistinguishable from harm.

Warnings

Describes an act of help performed with total conviction and catastrophic results, after which the helper remains certain they did the right thing.

It is a grave phrase. Unlike most Scrantonian warnings, it is rarely said aloud in front of the person who was helped.

In use

Gardener: He 'pruned' the rosebush for me while I was away.

Gardener: Dwight, Sprinkles in the freezer.

Etymology

From the account of Angela's cat, Sprinkles, old and ailing, whom Dwight was asked to look in on. Judging as a farmer that an animal with no quality of life should be spared its misery, he fed her antihistamines, sang her her favorite songs, and laid her in Angela's freezer. Confronted, he said he had taken care of the cat the best way he knew how, and that he had expected a hug.

Source

Season 4, Episode 1 — Fun Run.